My Thoughts: The Goddess Test (Aimee Carter)

The Goddess Test (Goddess Test, #1)EVERY GIRL WHO HAS TAKEN THE TEST HAS DIED.


It's always been just Kate and her mom--and her mother is dying. Her last wish? To move back to her childhood home. So Kate's going to start at a new school with no friends, no other family and the fear that her mother won't live past the fall.

Then she meets Henry. Dark. Tortured. And mesmerizing. He claims to be Hades, god of the Underworld--and if she accepts his bargain, he'll keep her mother alive while Kate tries to pass seven tests.

Kate is sure he's crazy--until she sees him bring a girl back from the dead. Now saving her mother seems crazily possible. If she suceeds, she'll become Henry's future bride and a goddess. (Goodreads blurb)

My Thoughts:
Okay so maybe it's time I just give up on Greek mythology re-tellings. (Other than the already established awesome by Rick Riordan).  The previously read Abandon by Meg Cabot left a horrible taste in my mouth and I was hoping to be refreshed by The Goddess Test.
Boy oh boy was I wrong. And disappointed. And frustrated. And bored.

The Goddess Test by Aimee Carter definitely helped me perfect my eye rolling technique. I came THIS close to not finishing, but managed to skim through to the end. I hatehatehate giving up on books in case there's the slightest chance of things turning around. Things, however,  only continued to go down hill until the torture finally let up and the book came to an end.
This is probably one of the worst young adult books I've ever read.
For everyone who liked it, I'm glad. Their shining reviews will help outshine my negative one.

Okay....where to start. I guess I'll start with the story itself. This was another retelling of the Greek mythology story of Hades and Persephone, greatly re-imagined. The book starts off confusing, which is never a good thing. We meet Henry and Diana and there's all these dead girls and Henry wants to give up and blahblahblah.
Then there's Kate, her mom's dying. She sees her un-friend friend Ava die. Then be brought back to life. Then die again. Then as a human again, oh i mean a ghost. And then they're instant besties. hooray. Henry tells Kate he will keep her mother alive if she lives with him. It's perfectly easy for Kate to believe and accept that Henry brought Ava back to life and then killed her again, but that he's a God..well that's just too ludicrous. 

The final actual premise of this book is this: Henry is Hades, and ruler of the in between.  Henry needs (wants) someone to be by his side, if not, he's going to give up his job to his relatives and fade into nothingness. So he keeps finding girls he thinks are "THE ONE" to take 7 tests. If they pass them all it means they are worthy of becoming immortal and staying by Henry's side. Wait, no that's wrong. Even if she passes, it's still up to his family to determine if she's worthy. Every girl has died up to this point. Kate is Henry's last hope. Oh, all the while Henry is still devastated and puppy-dog hung up on the death of his beloved, Persephone who actually didn't love him and chose to love a human and then subsequently died herself. 

A lot of people hate insta-love.  In this book, there was insta-friendships that made absolutely no sense, were not believable and had me acting crazy. All the characters were just surface characters, no depth, no life, no soul.  Kate was annoying. Ava was annoying.  The romance between Henry and Kate was tepid.  There was a lot of hypocrisy going on in things characters said or events that transpired.  I felt like the story was just BAMBAMBAM. No build-ups, no intensity, just this is the way it is and this is what happened next. I wasn't TAKEN ON a journey, I was told a story in a matter-of-fact voice.

This book was a definite struggle all the way through. It was boring and predictable and blah. Which makes me sad. Because I bought book 2 already and am never going to read it. EVER.

If you liked Abandon by Meg Cabot, there's a good chance you'll like this book. Otherwise, I would give it a pass.

Favorite Quotes:
"His eyes were the color of moonlight."

"I expected death to be cold. Instead the first thing I felt was warmth-incredible warmth that filled my body, or at least what was left of it, and spread through me like honey."

Bottom Line: The Goddess Test by Aimee Carter was a Greek mythology retelling gone wrong.  1.5/5


  1. What a bummer! I LOVE mythology re-tellings! This is one of the ones that I actually haven't read yet, but plan to eventually. Because of all of the mixed reviews, I'm SO CURIOUS about it.

    Persephone and Hades is my favorite classic myth, and then Psyche and Cupid. And I'm not joking when it comes to mythology either. I loved Everneath - it was Persephone and Hades - have you read that one and did you like it? I'm also reading The Song of Achilles right now and it is absolutely BLOWING MY MIND. By Madeline Miller. It's an adult book but WOW. So good. I highly recommend it. Don't give up!

    Thanks for honest thoughts on this one though! I'm so curious about it. So very curious.

    1. I was definitely bummed after reading this book, I haven't read Everneath or The Song of Achilles but I'll def have to check them out!do you already have this book..because if not you are welcome to mine, it doesn't look like I'll be rereading it..just let me know, if you want it it's yours. If you end up liking it you can keep it, if you end up liking it as much as I did you can just pass it along to someone else :)

    2. I actually have some of the others toward the end of this series but not this one, which is why I haven't started reading this series yet. If you really want to get rid of it, I'll be thrilled to take it. That's so generous and so awesome.

    3. Consider it done! My email address is runursie@yahoo.com just let me know where you want me to mail it to and it's all yours!